Home Fashion I Don’t Want To Be The Woman A Man Learns From Anymore
Fashion

I Don’t Want To Be The Woman A Man Learns From Anymore

Share
I Don’t Want To Be The Woman A Man Learns From Anymore
Share


I have spent an embarrassing amount of my life explaining to men why I am upset with them, as though I am presenting a case to a jury that is somehow both intellectually challenged and personally offended by the evidence. I would rehearse these conversations in the shower, while brushing my teeth, or halfway through eating something I had been looking forward to all day. I would carefully construct my sentences, remove anything that might hurt their fragile little egos, anticipate their objections and prepare examples because apparently being upset wasn’t enough; I also needed to submit supporting documentation. By the time we actually spoke, I had argued both sides, countered every defence and exhausted myself. And somehow, I would still end up having to explain the very thing they had done wrong to begin with.

I was very proud of how well I communicated and mentally pat myself, because what was that! I had learned to distinguish intention from impact, to say I feel instead of you always, to acknowledge somebody else’s perspective without abandoning my own. The trouble was that I had become so proficient at explaining my feelings that I rarely stopped to experience them. Even my anger had to make a convincing case for its existence.

download (81)
Photograph: (Pinterest)

I think this is one of the more absurd things about growing up as a woman who wants to be good at love. You begin with the ambition of being understood and gradually learn how to make yourself easier to understand, preferably without upsetting the person you love enough to derail the conversation. Sometimes you succeed, and he changes. Sometimes you succeed repeatedly, and the relationship ends anyway. What happens to all that learning afterward?

We have a cultural vocabulary for the person who changes our life. We call them formative, transformative or maybe unforgettable. In some rare cases few men actually speak fondly of former girlfriends who taught them how to communicate, how to be vulnerable, and how to recognise the difference between being right and being kind. These acknowledgements can be sincere and sometimes even moving. Yet I am fascinated by the assumption that the woman receiving them should feel rewarded for babysitting their newly found ‘inner emotional alter ego.’

Being told that somebody has become a better partner because of you is a complicated compliment when you spent much of the relationship wishing he would become one while you were still together. Because this Bob The Buildersituation is for free.

Marriage-Story-059
Photograph: (Pinterest)


In Noah Baumbach’s 
Marriage Story (2019), Charlie reads Nicole’s letter about what she once loved about him near the end of their divorce. It is an immensely tender scene, partly because he finally hears her words without needing to argue with them. I remember being moved by that, and then feeling rather annoyed by how moving I found it. The film gives us the emotional satisfaction of his understanding while allowing us to recognise that understanding has come too late to save the marriage. I wonder whether we sometimes mistake the beauty of a belated realisation for a consolation to the person who needed it sooner.

I have begun to think about this as a problem of memory. Two people can remember the same relationship with extraordinary accuracy and still produce completely different accounts of what happened. He remembers the evening he finally understood why his behaviour was hurtful. She remembers the months during which she struggled to make him understand. His memory is organised around the moment of discovery; hers contains all the unsuccessful attempts that preceded it. What becomes a turning point in one person’s life can remain an accumulation of ordinary disappointments in another’s. And because personal growth makes such a satisfying story, the version with the breakthrough often wins. 

30e0460cf7d6602c9073231a869f13c2
Photograph: (Pinterest)


Psychologist Dan McAdams has written about
redemptive sequences, the stories we construct in which difficult experiences lead to positive outcomes. I find myself returning to this idea when I think about relationships, because I recognise how desperately I have sometimes wanted my own heartbreak to mean something. I have gone back over conversations looking for evidence that I became wiser, stronger, more discerning. I have tried to identify what I learned because the alternative was admitting that I had spent a great deal of time loving somebody and had come away terribly sad. It is difficult to accept that an experience can be important without having improved you in some measurable way.

A woman can have helped somebody become kinder and still wish she had been treated more kindly. His transformation does not retrospectively make her experience a good one. Arlie Russell Hochschild’s writing on emotion management offers another way to understand the work involved in sustaining relationships. What interests me is how easily that work becomes invisible once it succeeds. When a man learns to apologise without becoming defensive, the improvement belongs to him. The conversations and emotional calculations that helped him get there become part of the relationship’s history, usually remembered only by the person who performed them. Success can erase the evidence of the effort required to produce it.

0870e3d6fbbec41e56cf1dc79cbb995af531e7a344655c0e455c7a4617dc467a._SX1080_FMjpg_
Photograph: (Pinterest)


Virginia Woolf’s
A Room of One’s Ownmakes me think about a different kind of cost. Woolf was concerned with the independence women need to write, but I keep thinking about how much room a woman is allowed inside her own relationship. I remember the afternoons I have spent distracted by an unresolved argument, checking my phone when I could have been reading, writing, or enjoying an ordinary day. I sometimes resent how much of my attention I have willingly surrendered to the business of being understood. I cannot recover those afternoons by discovering that the conversations eventually made somebody else a better communicator. And yet, I wonder how many of them I would willingly surrender again, simply because being needed by somebody I loved made me feel important. It is an uncomfortable thought, especially when I consider how easily I have confused being indispensable with being cherished.

publive-image


I have also wondered whether I was always as generous as I believed. Sometimes my patience came with the expectation that it would eventually be rewarded. I wanted the person I loved to recognise how much effort I was making and respond with the same care. It is difficult to admit how many private bargains I made in love without telling anybody.

Of course, I have needed patience too. I have misunderstood people I loved, struggled to apologise, and expected reassurance without always knowing how to ask for it. Any honest account of intimacy must allow for the fact that we are all unfinished people, capable of hurting each other while trying, sometimes sincerely, to do better. I would hate to live in a world where everybody was expected to become emotionally accomplished before being considered worthy of love. What I want to question is the distribution of responsibility. Who notices when a relationship needs work, who initiates the uncomfortable conversations, and who gets to be unreasonable without having to explain themselves with perfect composure?

past lives
Photograph: (Pinterest)


I still want the men I have loved to be happy. I hope their future relationships contain fewer of the arguments that once occupied so much of mine. It would be depressing to believe that we could spend years knowing somebody and leave each other entirely unchanged. 

But I am learning to separate wishing somebody well from needing to find consolation in their improvement. I can be glad that a man learned something from loving me without considering his education the purpose of our relationship. I was there to share a life with him, to be ridiculous and difficult and affectionate, to eat dinner together, to be held when I was sad, to have somebody remember how I liked my tea. I had my own growing up to do, and I wanted somebody beside me while I did it.

I would love, for once, to be remembered less for what I taught a man and more for how much fun we had learning to love each other.

Also, read:

The Digital Breadcrumbs We Leave Behind After A Relationship Ends



Source link

Share